|
|
|
| Innovation Policy Mix: a Literature Review and Prospects |
| Ma Wencong,Ye Yangping,Chen Xiude |
| (School of Management,Guangdong University of Technology,Guangzhou 510520,China) |
|
|
|
|
Abstract Innovation policy mix is one of the hot issues in the field of policy research,which has attracted more and more scholars' attention.Through sorting out the relevant domestic and foreign literatures on innovation policy mix,this paper describes the origin and connotation of the concept of policy mix,and makes a statistical analysis of the number and important literature published in the literature on innovation policy mix.On this basis,it further clarifies the development vein and theoretical framework of the innovation policy mix,and analyzes the research status of the innovation policy mix from the dimensions,elements,process and characteristics.Finally,according to the shortages of the existing research,the main directions of future research are proposed,which can provide theoretical basis and knowledge base for further expanding the research in this field.
|
|
Received: 02 June 2020
|
|
|
|
|
|
| [1] KIVIMAA P,KERN F.Creative destruction or mere niche support? innovation policy mixes for sustainability transitions[J].Research Policy,2016,45(1): 205-217.[2] OECD. The innovation policy mix[R].Paris: OECD Publishing,2010.[3] FLANAGAN K,UYARRA E,LARANJA M.Reconceptualising the "policy mix" for innovation[J].Research Policy,2011(40): 702-713.[4] OECD. Policy mix for business R&D and innovation[R].Paris: OECD Publishing,2016.[5] KERN F,ROGGE K S,HOWLETT M.Policy mixes for sustainability transitions: new approaches and insights through bridging innovation and policy studies[J].Research Policy,2019(9): 103832. [6] BORRS S,EDQUIST C.The choice of innovation policy instruments[J].Technological Forecasting & Social Change,2013,80(8): 1513-1522. [7] RAVEN R,WALRAVE B.Overcoming transformational failures through policy mixes in the dynamics of technological innovation systems[J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change,2020(153): 119297. [8] ROGGE K S,REICHARDT K.Policy mixes for sustainability transitions: an extended concept and framework for analysis[J].Research Policy,2016,45(8): 1620-1635. [9] MAGRO E,WILSON J R.Complex innovation policy systems: towards an evaluation mix[J].Research Policy,2013,42(9): 1647-1656.[10] DUMONT M.Assessing the policy mix of public support to business R&D[J].Research Policy,2017,46(10): 1851-1862.[11] BRESSERS J T A, O'TOOLE L J.Instrument selection and implementation in a networked context[A].ELIADES P,HILL M M,HOWLETT M.Designing government: from instruments to governance[M].Quebec:McGill-Quenn's University Press,2005.[12] MAVROT C,HADORN S,SAGER F.Mapping the mix: linking instruments,settings and target groups in the study of policy mixes[J].Research Policy,2019,48(10): 103614.[13] MAGRO E,WILSON J R.Policy-mix evaluation: governance challenges from new place-based innovation policies[J].Research Policy,2019,48(10): 103612.[14] RADICIC D,PUGH G.R&D programmes,policy mix,and the "European paradox": evidence from European SMEs[J].Science & Public Policy,2016,44(4).[15] LANAHAN L,FELDMAN M P.Multilevel innovation policy mix: a closer look at state policies that augment the federal SBIR program[J].Research Policy,2015,44(7): 1387-1402. [16] MONTMARTIN B,HERRERA M.Internal and external effects of R&D subsidies and fiscal incentives: empirical evidence using spatial dynamic panel models[J].Research Policy,2015,44(5): 1065-1079.[17] MONTMARTIN B,HERRERA M,MASSARD N.The impact of the French policy mix on business and R&D : how geography matters[J].Research Policy,2018,47(10): 2010-2027. [18] NEICU D.Evaluating the effects of an R&D policy mix of subsidies and tax credits[J].Management and Economics Review,2019,4(2): 1-13.[19] RADAS S,ANICI D,TAFRO A,et al.The effects of public support schemes on small and medium enterprises[J].Technovation,2015(38): 15-30.[20] HOTTENROTT H,LOPES BENTO C,VEUGELERS R.Direct and cross scheme effects in R&D subsidy programs[J].Research Policy,2017,46(6): 1118-1132.[21] HUERGO E,MORENO L.Subsidies or loans? evaluating the impact of R&D support programmes[J].Research Policy,2017,46(7): 1198-1214.[22] VEUGELERS R.Which policy instruments to induce clean innovating[J].Research Policy,2012,41(10): 1770-1778.[23] 郭元源，葛江宁，程聪，等.基于清晰集定性比较分析方法的科技创新政策组合供给模式研究[J].软科学,2019,33(1): 45-49.[24] GUERZONI M,RAITERI E.Demand-side vs.supply-side technology policies: hidden treatment and new empirical evidence on the policy mix[J].Research Policy,2015,44(3): 726-747.[25] 豆士婷，刘佳，庞守林.科技政策组合的技术创新协同效应研究——供给侧—需求侧视角[J].科技进步与对策， 2019,36(22): 118-126.[26] CANTNER U,GRAF H,HERRMANN J,et al.Inventor networks in renewable energies: the influence of the policy mix in Germany[J].Research Policy，2016,45(6): 1165-1184.[27] KALCHEVA I,PING M L,PANT S.Innovation:the interplay between demand-side shock and supply-side environment [J].Research Policy，2018,47(2): 440-461.[28] FERNANDEZ-SASTRE J, MONTALVO-QUIZHPI F.The effect of developing countries' innovation policies on firms' decisions to invest in R&D[J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change， 2019,143: 214-223. [29] HOWLETT M,RAYNER J. Design principles for policy mixes:cohesion and coherence in "new governance arrangements"[J].Policy & Society， 2007,26(4): 1-18.[30] HOWLETT M,RAYNER J.Patching vs packaging in policy formulation: assessing policy portfolio design[J].Politics & Governance,2013,1(2): 170-182.[31] REICHARDT K,NEGRO S O,ROGGE K S,et al.Analyzing interdependencies between policy mixes and technological innovation systems: the case of offshore wind in Germany[J].Technological Forecasting & Social Change，2016（106）: 11-21.[32] EDMONDSON D L,KERN F,ROGGE K S.The co-evolution of policy mixes and socio-technical systems: towards a conceptual framework of policy mix feedback in sustainability transitions[J].Research Policy， 2019,48(10): 1035-1055.[33] ROGGE K S,SCHLEICH J.Do policy mix characteristics matter for low-carbon innovation? a survey-based exploration of renewable power generation technologies in Germany[J].Research Policy， 2018,47(9): 1639-1654.[34] UYARRA E,SHAPIRA P,HARDING A.Low carbon innovation and enterprise growth in the UK: challenges of a place-blind policy mix[J].Technological Forecasting & Social Change， 2016（103）: 264-272.[35] REICHARDT K,ROGGE K.How the policy mix impacts innovation: findings from company case studies on offshore wind in Germany[J].Environmental Innovation & Societal Transitions,2016（18）: 62-81.[36] 徐喆，李春艳.我国科技政策组合特征及其对产业创新的影响研究[J].科学学研究,2017,35(1): 45-53.[37] 郭雯，陶凯，李振国.政策组合对领先市场形成的影响分析——以新能源汽车产业为例[J].科研管理,2018,39(12): 30-36.[38] COSTANTINI V,CRESPI F,PALMA A.Characterizing the policy mix and its impact on eco-innovation:a patent analysis of energy-efficient technologies[J].Research Policy， 2017,46(4): 799-819.[39] 孟维站，徐喆，刘宇佳，等.我国科技政策组合特征对高技术产业创新效率的分阶段影响[J].经济问题，2019(6): 49-54. |
|
|
|
