|
|
|
| Review on the Mindset and Its Relationship with Related Concepts Concerning Creativity |
| Zhao Hui1,Zhang Jianwei2,Zhang Zhen1,Heng Shupeng1 |
| （1.Faculty of Education,Henan Normal University,Xinxiang 453007,China;2.School of Humanities and Social Science,Beijing Institute of Technology,Beijing 100081,China） |
|
|
|
|
Abstract The number-one trait underpinning creative achievement stems from the mindset.Analysis of the relationship between mindset and related concepts concerning creativity not only lays the foundation for the further development of implicit personality theory research,but also deepens and expands the research scope of creativity.This paper aims at the discussion the latest research progress of mindset in the field of creation.In addition,it also discusses the concept,theoretical bases,the measurements and experiments of mindset.Finally,the future research prospects are proposed.The study provides a theoretical reference for innovative research and scientific decision-making.
|
|
Received: 21 November 2019
|
|
|
|
|
|
| [1] TAY L,KUYKENDALL L.Promoting happiness：the malleability of individual and societal subjective wellbeing[J].International Journal of Psychology,2013,48(3)：159-176.[2] DWECK C S.Mindset：the new psychology of success[M].New York：Random House,2006.[3] HESLIN P A,KEATING L A.In learning mode? the role of mindsets in derailing and enabling experiential leadership development[J].The Leadership Quarterly,2017,28(3)：367-384.[4] RAVENSCROFT S,WAYMIRE T R,WEST T.Accounting students' metacognition：the assocition of performance,calibration error and mindset[J].Issues in Accounting Education,2012,27(3)：707-732.[5] DINGER F C,DICKHUSER O,SPINATH B,et al.Antecedents and consequences of students' achievement goals：a mediation analysis[J].Learning & Individual Differences,2013 (28)：90-101.[6] LIU C H,CHIU F C,CHEN H C,et al.Helpful but insufficient：incremental theory on challenge-confronting tendencies for students who fear being laughed at[J].Motivation and Emotion,2014,38(3)：367.[7] SHEN C,MIELE D B,VASILYEVA M.The relation between college students' academic mindsets and their persistence during math problem solving[J].Psychology in Russia,2016,9(3)：38-56.[8] HASS R W,KATZ-BUONINCONTRO J,REITER-PALMON R.Disentangling creative mindsets from creative self-efficacy and creative identity：do people hold fixed and growth theories of creativity[J].Psychology of Aesthetics,Creativity,and the Arts,2016,10(4)：436.[9] CSIKSZENTMIHALYI M.Implications of a systems perspective for the study of creativity[M].Cambridge：Cambridge University Press,1999：313-338.[10] KARWOWSKI M.Creative mindsets：measurement,correlates,consequences[J].Psychology of Aesthetics,Creativity,and the Arts,2014,8(1)：62.[11] O'CONNOR A J,NEMETH C J,AKUTSU S.Consequences of beliefs about the malleability of creativity[J].Creativity Research Journal,2013,25(2)：155-162.[12] BEGHETTO R A.Creative mortification：an initial exploration[J].Psychology of Aesthetics,Creativity,and the Arts,2014,8(3)：266.[13] ROYSTON R P.The relationship between big-c,little-c,and pro-creativity and fixed and malleable creative mindsets[D].Omaha：University of Nebraska,2016.[14] GIBSON S.Creating solutions instead of solving problems：emerging roles for technical services departments[J].Technical Services Quarterly,2016,33(2)：145-153.[15] DWECK C S,SORICH L.Mastery-oriented thinking[M].New York：Oxford University Press,1999.[16] YEAGER D S,DWECK C S.Mindsets that promote resilience：when students believe that personal characteristics can be developed[J].Educational Psychologist,2012,47(4)：302-314.[17] TABERNERO C,WOOD R E.Implicit theories versus the social construal of ability in self-regulation and performance on a complex task[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,1999,78(2)：104-127.[18] MURPHY M C,DWECK C S.A culture of genius：how an organization's lay theory shapes people's cognition,affect,and behavior[J].Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,2010,36(3)：283-296.[19] HONG Y,CHIU C,DWECK C S,et al.Implicit theories,attributions,and coping：a meaning system approach[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1999,77(3)：588-599.[20] MATHUR P,CHUN H E H,MAHESWARAN D.Consumer mindsets and self-enhancement：signaling versus learning[J].Journal of Consumer Psychology,2016,26(1)：142-152.[21] DWECK C S.Self-theories：their role in motivation,personality,and development[M].London：Psychology Press,2000.[22] BLACKWELL L S,TRZESNIEWSKI K H,DWECK C S.Implicit theories of intelligence predict achievement across an adolescent transition：a longitudinal study and an intervention[J].Child Development,2007,78(1)：246-263.[23] JEGATHESAN M,VITBERG Y M,PUSIC M V.A survey of mindset theories of intelligence and medical error self-reporting among pediatric house staff and faculty[J].Bmc Medical Education,2016,16(1)：1-6.[24] RYDELL R J,HUGENBERG K,RAY D,et al.Implicit theories about groups and stereotyping：the role of group entitativity[J].Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,2007,33(4)：549-558.[25] BECKMANN N,WOOD R E,MINBASHIAN A,et al.Small group learning：do group members' implicit theories of ability make a difference[J].Learning and Individual Differences,2012,22(5)：624-631.[26] HEIDER F.The psychology of interpersonal relations[M].New York：Wiley,1958.[27] KELLY G A.The psychology of personal constructs[M].New York：Norton and Company,1955.[28] DWECK C S,CHIU C,HONG Y.Implicit theories and their role in judgments and reactions：a word from two perspectives[J].Psychological Inquiry,1995,6(4)：267-285.[29] TARBETSKY A L,COLLIE R J,MARTIN A J.The role of implicit theories of intelligence and ability in predicting achievement for Indigenous(Aboriginal) Australian students[J].Contemporary Educational Psychology,2016 (47)：61-71.[30] MACNAMARA B N,RUPANI N S.The relationship between intelligence and mindset[J].Intelligence,2017 (64)：52-59.[31] NUSSBAUM A D,DWECK C S.Defensiveness versus remediation：self-theories and modes of self-esteem maintenance[J].Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,2008,34(5)：599-612.[32] YORKSTON E A,NUNES J C,MATTA S.The malleable brand：the role of implicit theories in evaluating brand extensions[J].Journal of Marketing,2010,74(1)：80-93.[33] GADGIL S.Understanding the interaction between students' theories of intelligence and learning activities[D].Pittsburgh：University of Pittsburgh,2014.[34] PLAKS J E,GRANT H,DWECK C S.Violations of implicit theories and the sense of prediction and control：implications for motivated person perception[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2005,88(2)：245.[35] TIERNEY P M,FARMER S.Leader behavior,creativity,and the creative self-concept[C].New York,2007.[36] PUENTE-DAZ R,CAVAZOS-ARROYO J.The influence of creative mindsets on achievement goals,enjoyment,creative self-efficacy and performance among business students[J].Thinking Skills & Creativity,2017 (24)：1-11.[37] STEELE L M,JOHNSON G,MEDEIROS K E.Looking beyond the generation of creative ideas：confidencein evaluating ideas predicts creative outcomes[J].Personalityand Individual Differences,2018,125：21-29.[38] COELHO F,AUGUSTO M.Job characteristics and the creativity of frontline service employees[J].Journal of Service Research,2010,13(4)：426-438.[39] WICKES K N S.Developing creative competencies in adolescence：comparing implicit theories and creative abilities in the gifted and non-gifted adolescent[D].Texas：Texas A & M University,2004.[40] PUENTE-DAZ R.Achievement goals and emotions[J].The Journal of Psychology：Interdisciplinary and Applied,2013,147：245-259.[41] DWECK C S.Motivational processes affecting learning[J].American Psychologist,1986,41(10)：1040.[42] JOHN D R,JI K P.Mindsets matter：implications for branding research and practice[J].Journal of Consumer Psychology,2016,26(1)：153-160.[43] RICHARDS R.Everyday creativity：our hidden potential[M].Washington,DC：American Psychological Association,2007：25-53.[44] BEGHETTO R A,DILLEY A E.Creative aspirations or pipe dreams?toward understanding creative mortification in children and adolescents[J].New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development,2016 (151)：85-95.[45] BEGHETTO R A.Killing ideas softly?the promise and perils of creativity in theclassroom[M].Charlotte,NC：Information Age Publishing,2013.[46] ELLIOTT E S,DWECK C S.Goals：an approach to motivation and achievement[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1988,54(1)：5.[47] KENCH D,HAZELHURST S,OTULAJA F.Grit and growth mindset among high school students in a computer programming project：a mixed methods study[C].Annual Conference of the Southern African Computer Lecturers' Association,2016：187-194.[48] DORON J,STEPHAN Y,BOICH J,et al.Coping with examinations：exploring relationships between students' coping strategies,implicit theories of ability,and perceived control[J].British Journal of Educational Psychology,2009,79(3)：515-528.[49] STERNBERG R J,LUBART T I.Investing in creativity[J].American Psychologist,1996,51(3)：229-232.[50] MUMFORD M D,HESTER K S,ROBLEDO I C,et al.Mental models and creative problem-solving：the relationship of objective and subjective model attributes[J].Creativity Research Journal,2012,24(4)：311-330.[51] DONOHUE S K,HUNTER W G S,RICHARDS L G.Work in progress：creativity,mindset,and implications for engineering design instruction[C].Frontiers in Education Conference (FIE),2012：1-2.[52] GUCCIARDI D F,JACKSON B,HODGE K,et al.Implicit theories of mental toughness：relations with cognitive,motivational,and behavioral correlates[J].Sport,Exercise,and Performance Psychology,2015,4(2)：100.[53] 白新文,齐舒婷,明晓东,等.骏马易见,伯乐难寻:决策者心智模式影响创意识别的机制及边界条件[J].心理科学进展,2019,27(4)：571-586.[54] MUELLER J S,MELWANI S,LOEWENSTEIN J,et al.Reframing the decision-makers' dilemma：towards a social context model of creative idea recognition[J].Academy of Management Journal,2018,61(1)：94-110.[55] WARREN F,MASON-APPS E,HOSKINS S,et al.The role of implicit theories,age,and gender in the creative performance of children and adults[J].Thinking Skills and Creativity,2018,28：98-109.[56] ROYSTON R,REITER-PALMON R.Creative self-efficacy as mediator between creative mindsets and creative problem-solving[J].The Journal of Creative Behavior,2017(7)：1-10.[57] SCHRODER H S,MORAN T P,DONNELLAN M B,et al.Mindset induction effects on cognitive control：a neurobehavioral investigation[J].Biological Psychology,2014,103(1)：27.[58] TIRRI K,KUJALA T.Students' mindsets for learning and their neural underpinnings[J].Psychology,2016,7(9)：1231-1239.[59] MAKEL M C.The malleability of implicit beliefs of creativity and creative production[D].Bloomington：Indiana University,2008.[60] HEINE S J,KITAYAMA S,LEHMAN D R,et al.Divergent consequences of success and failure in Japan and north America：an investigation of self-improving motivations and malleable selves[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2001,81(4)：599.[61] TANG M,WERNER C,KARWOWSKI M.Differences in creative mindset between Germany and Poland：the mediating effect of individualism and collectivism[J].Thinking Skills and Creativity,2016 (21)：31-40.[62] SCHMIDT J A,SHUMOW L,KACKAR-CAM H Z.Does mindset intervention predict students' daily experience in classrooms?a comparison of seventh and ninth graders' trajectories[J].Journal of Youth and Adolescence,2017,46(3)：582-602.[63] O'BRIEN K,LOMAS T.Developing a growth mindset through outdoor personal development：can an intervention underpinned by psychology increase the impact of an outdoor learning course for young people[J].Journal of Adventure Education & Outdoor Learning,2017,17(2)：133-147.[64] OROSZ G,PTER-SZARKA S,BTHE B,et al.How not to do a mindset intervention：learning from a mindset intervention among students with good grades[J].Frontiers in Psychology,2017 (8)：311.[65] BRASS J,NIU W.The impact of implicit self-theory on rated creativity in third- and sixth-graders[J].Creativity Research Journal,2016,28(3)：318-327. |
|
|
|
