The Dilemmas and the Irrational Risks of Measuring Scientific Research Integrity: A Theoretical Reflection on the Technical Approaches to the External Norms of Scientific Research Integrity
Liu Shengli1,2,Pan Yuntao2
(1. Library, Archives and Information Center, Henan Normal University, Xinxiang 453007, China;2. Scientometrics & Evaluation Research Center, Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China, Beijing 100038, China)
刘胜利,潘云涛. 科研诚信的度量困境与非理性风险——面向科研诚信外部规范技术进路的学理反思[J]. 科技进步与对策, 2023, 40(20): 21-29.
Liu Shengli,Pan Yuntao. The Dilemmas and the Irrational Risks of Measuring Scientific Research Integrity: A Theoretical Reflection on the Technical Approaches to the External Norms of Scientific Research Integrity. SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY PROGRESS AND POLICY, 2023, 40(20): 21-29.
[1] 大卫·古斯顿, 龚旭. 在政治与科学之间:确保科学研究的诚信和产出率 [M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2011. [2] 刘胜利, 潘云涛, 赵筱媛. 科研诚信外部规范合目的性与合规律性的理论分析 [J]. 现代情报, 2020, 40(9):53-59. [3] LI T. Five ways China must cultivate research integrity [J]. Nature, 2019, 575(7784): 589-591. [4] TITUS S L, WELLS J A, RHOADES L J. Repairing research integrity [J]. Nature, 2008, 453(7198): 980-982. [5] FOGARTY T J. Show me the money:academic research as currency [J]. Accounting Education, 2009, 18(1): 3-6. [6] QUAN W, CHEN B, SHU F, et al. Publish or impoverish: an investigation of the monetary reward system of science in China (1999-2016) [J]. Aslib Proceedings, 2017, 69(5): 486-502. [7] VANI K, GUPTA D. Detection of idea plagiarism using syntax–semantic concept extractions with genetic algorithm [J]. Expert Systems with Applications, 2017, 73: 11-26. [8] ROOSTAEE M, SADREDDINI M H, FAKHRAHMAD S M. An effective approach to candidate retrieval for cross-language plagiarism detection:a fusion of conceptual and keyword-based schemes [J]. Information Processing & Management, 2020, 57(2): 102150. [9] AHUJA L, GUPTA V, KUMAR R. A new hybrid technique for detection of plagiarism from text documents [J]. Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, 2020, 45(12): 9939-9952. [10] NATIONAL ACADEMIES OF SCIENCES E, MEDICINE. Reproducibility and replicability in science [M]. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2019. [11] RESNIK D B, NEAL T, RAYMOND A, et al. Research misconduct definitions adopted by U.S. research institutions [J]. Accountability in Research, 2015, 22(1): 14-21. [12] MACILWAIN C. Scientific misconduct: more cops, more robbers[J]. Cell, 2012, 149(7): 1417-1419. [13] BENJAMINI Y. Selective inference: the silent killer of replicability [J]. Harvard Data Science Review, 2020, 4(2):1-31. [14] ZUCKERMAN H. Is "the time ripe" for quantitative research on misconduct in science [J]. Quantitative Science Studies, 2020,1(3): 945-958. [15] NICHOLS J D, OLI M K, KENDALL W L, et al. Opinion:a better approach for dealing with reproducibility and replicability in science [J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2021, 118(7):e2100769118. [16] LEWANDOWSKY S, BISHOP D. Research integrity:don't let transparency damage science [J]. Nature, 2016, 529(7587): 459-461. [17] FANELLI D. Is science really facing a reproducibility crisis, and do we need it to[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2018, 115(11): 2628-2631. [18] MARTIN B R. Whither research integrity?plagiarism, self-plagiarism and coercive citation in an age of research assessment [Z]. Elsevier，2013: 1005-14. [19] 廖苗. 科学的社会契约与后常规科学 [J]. 自然辩证法研究, 2014, 30(10): 54-59. [20] 唐壮, 聂培琴. 建立并完善道德自律和法律规制互动的科研诚信体系 [J]. 科研管理, 2008,29(S1): 98-100,90. [21] 道格拉斯·C.诺思. 制度、制度变迁与经济绩效 [M]. 杭行,译.上海: 格致出版社, 2014. [22] 徐国栋. 诚实信用原则二题 [J]. 法学研究, 2002, 24(4):74-88. [23] 徐国栋. 英语世界中的诚信原则 [J]. 环球法律评论, 2004, 26(3): 366-375. [24] SHANNON C E. A mathematical theory of communication [J]. The Bell System Technical Journal, 1948, 27(3): 379-423. [25] 刘胜利, 潘云涛, 赵筱媛. 科研数据造假判定实用情报策略与技术的宏观考量 [J]. 现代情报, 2017, 37(12):3-9. [26] 徐国栋. 客观诚信与主观诚信的对立统一问题——以罗马法为中心 [J]. 中国社会科学, 2001,22(6): 97-113,206. [27] 迈克尔·马尔凯. 科学社会学理论与方法 [M]. 林聚任,等，译.北京: 商务印书馆, 2006. [28] FRANCISL.MACRINA. 科研诚信:负责任的科研行为教程与案例 [M].北京：高等教育出版社, 2011. [29] 波普尔. 科学发现的逻辑 [M]. 查汝强, 邱仁宗, 万木春，译.杭州: 中国美术学院出版社, 2008. [30] 李真真, 黄小茹. 中国科研诚信面临的突出问题及解决路径 [J]. 科学与社会, 2017, 7(3):107-120. [31] 桑本谦. 私人之间的监控与惩罚:一个经济学的进路 [M].济南：山东人民出版社, 2005. [32] 马建平. 一稿多投正当性的法理分析及其权利规制 [J]. 现代出版, 2012,19(3): 18-21. [33] NOSEK B A, ALTER G, BANKS G C, et al. Promoting an open research culture [J]. Science, 2015, 348(6242): 1422-1425. [34] MAYO-WILSON E, GRANT S, SUPPLEE L, et al. Evaluating implementation of the transparency and openness promotion guidelines:the TRUST process for rating journal policies, procedures, and practices [J]. Research Integrity and Peer Review, 2021, 6(1): 1-11.
